I agree with most everything negative said here about this situation. There was also a comment made by a poster on ATL that resonated with me:
"If your law school doesn't think you are worthy of a scholarship to defray the cost of your education, why the hell should a bunch of strangers subsidize it?"
That's a great insight--the law school saw her whole application and knew her financial situation, but chose not to take further action. That speaks volumes.
You know, that's funny, because I thought the exact same thing you did when I saw that comment. If you're a student a school really, truly wants, and you demonstrate financial need, they will get you the help you need. Now, granted, some of that may be in :: GASP :: student loans, but you do what you have to do. Schools go out for applicants they want. UNC's reaction says a little more about her particular application and stats.